Cleric Spells Typo?

[keith418]

Cleric spells typo?

In my Whitebox edition, there are six Cleric spells listed for the fourth level:

Level 4
1. Cure (Cause) Serious
Wounds
2. Neutralize Poison
3. Protection from Chaos
(Law),
4. 10 ft. radius
5. Speak with Plants
6. Sticks to Snakes

Number 4 looks like a typo. It looks like it is supposed to be part of spell number 3. Is the 4th spell supposed to be "Create water"? "Create food and drink" is listed as being one of the 5th level spells.

Thanks and sorry of this has been asked before...

[Azafuse]

It should be a typo concerning Protection from Chaos/Law, 10 ft. radius, which appears "doubled" also in the MU's spell list (p38 of the 3rd Printing).

[keith418]

The question I have is whether or not the intention was to add another spell there on the list - like "create water" or not have that number at all and let "create food and drink" in the 5th list cover it.

In the OD&D LBB copy I have, it lists "create water" as another spell on that list and then has "create food" in the 5th list. This has been changed in S&W, presumably, to just "create food & water" on the 5th list.

In my own game, I am house ruling it back to the original.

[Azafuse]

According to the rules, there are 5 spells (instead of 6) listed as C4 and 12 spells (instead of 13) listed as M3: under this point of view it is a typo.

Talking about 2 spells in M&M becoming 1 in WB, I think the reason is simply the OGL.

[Finarvyn]

Yeah, a bizarre typo and I'm surprised I never caught it before. There should only be 5 spells in the list.

[premmy]

Actually, that's an awesome spell: Create 10' Radius.

Just the thing when the party needs to create a 10' radius.

[Sean Michael Kelly]

Jan 3, 2012 6:39:03 GMT -6 premmy said:

Actually, that's an awesome spell: Create 10' Radius.

Just the thing when the party needs to create a 10' radius.

I could use one right now. I'm at Starbucks.